Structuring Joint Ventures - Term Sheets and Agreements
1. Preparing for Negotiations
"What is the economic rationale underlying the planned JV?" To answer this question seriously is particularly important for the "weaker partner" because he may have more to lose should the JV go wrong. The "weakness" may result from owning the smaller stake or holding fewer voting rights in the JV Company or from lacking know-how, market access, or in less open countries, from the "stigma" of being a foreign investor not familiar with the "home rule".
Does the "weaker partner" want to prop up his local majority partner with his know-how, or to get access to cheaper production or a new market, or is he just looking for a profitable investment? Depending on the answer he will be seen either as a "strategic partner" or a "financial partner". As a strategic partner, he will
- seek an assured level of influence over the corporate bodies of the JV company and insist on the right to delegate nominees to them, allocate "strategic" responsibilities to such nominees,
- be interested in a long duration of the JV,
- stabilize the relationship with the majority partner by putting restrictions on the transfer of the latter's participation,
- carefully draw up accompanying agreements of the JV company with third parties (e.g., supply, procurement of know-how, intellectual property). As a financial partner he will rather focus on
- influence over financial matters (including minority rights relating to financial control and audit), the right to nominate the Chief Financial Officer,
- a pre-defined lifetime of the JV and a pre-defined exit (e.g., an Initial Public Offering).
In either case, the weaker partner would be well advised to retain counsel familiar with the strengths of the majority partner.

2. Letter of Intent
The Term Sheet or Letter of Intent (LOI), which precedes the Definitive Agreement, is a confidential document, usually prepared by the buyer or investor, which outlines in general terms the purchase or investment agreement between the parties. All of the following are the same thing: term sheet, memorandum of understanding (MOU), letter of intent (LOI), heads of agreement, deal points, etc. Most of the time it is not a legally binding commitment to buy, sell, or invest. However, certain provisions such as confidentiality stand still and payment of consultants during the diligence period should be and usually are binding. I refer to the LOI as a handshake in writing. The main purpose is to assure that the parties agree on the general terms of the deal before starting due diligence. Without the terms written, the parties will expose themselves to crucial ambiguities and omissions.
While subscription members receive all files on this site, some files from that package can be purchased individually without the need for a membership. These files are always shown with the "View Now" and "Add to Cart" buttons beside them.
Click Add to Cart to Buy Each Document - Download link for files provided immediately after purchase. As a reminder, subscription members receive these files in their private download area at no additional cost.
Term Sheet/Letter of Intent Template |
Click Box For Free View of Each Document |
Place An Order |
Joint Venture - M&A07 |
||
Product Distribution - M&A08 |
||
Product License - M&A09 |
||
Technology Development - M&A10 |
||
Asset Purchase - M&A01 |
||
Asset Purchase - M&A02 |
||
Stock For Cash & Stock Purchase - M&A03 |
||
Stock For Cash Purchase - M&A04 |
||
Stock for Stock Purchase - M&A05 |
||
Earnout Purchase - M&A06 |
||
Series A Preferred - M&A11 |
||
Series B Preferred - M&A12 |
Setting up a Joint Venture Step-by-Step - Click Here To View | Buying or Selling a Business Step-by-Step Procedure - Click Here To View |
![]()
|
|
Download Additional Agreement and Term Sheet Templates
For Annual Subscription Members
Only
As the weaker partner will be in the more vulnerable position;
confidentiality is essential, and exclusivity of negotiations with the
stronger partner for, at least, a certain time period. In order not to
lose face at a later stage, an understanding should be established to value assets and what the price-relevant factors shall be.
In the interest of the weaker partner, the due diligence examination should be both intense and expeditious. "Red files", if they
cannot be avoided, should be accessible for the minority partner as
early as possible, i.e., after the merger-control clearance is obtained.
3. Due Diligence Examination
The minority partner should insist on a well-organized and complete data
room. On the other hand, he should not formally acknowledge any
"completeness" of the information he has obtained, and
certainly not if it is demanded together with a waiver of any warranty
relating to "facts that could have been seen from the information
provided". More generally, the minority partner should not accept a
reduction of the representations and warranties to be granted by the
majority partner with the latter's argument that "an extensive
due diligence examination of assets the majority partner is to
contribute to the joint venture vehicle was granted".
a) In particular, the minority partner should insist upon a proper
definition of the purpose of the JV. This will help when the
interpretation of the JV agreements are at stake.
The minority partner should also insist that the majority partner shall
terminate its own (or its affiliates) competing activities and to
completely transfer to the JV company the existing customers, suppliers,
key personnel, etc.
b) As far as the JV vehicle is concerned, the minority partner might
prefer a type of corporation where the directors are not subject to
direct instructions of the shareholder meeting.
The minority partner should aim to have as many minority rights as
possible established in the articles so that they work as statutory
rights (e.g., the right to delegate members of corporate bodies,
restrictions on the transfer of shares, preferred dividends). In
particular, he should secure his right of veto for resolutions on
specific, important matters by establishing a higher statutory quorum so
that no resolution would be valid without his presence at the meeting.
While subscription members receive all files on this site, some files from that package can be purchased individually without the need for a membership. These files are always shown with the "View Now" and "Add to Cart" buttons beside them.
Click Add to Cart to Buy Each Document - Download link for files provided immediately after purchase. As a reminder, subscription members receive these files in their private download area at no additional cost.
Definitive Agreement Template |
Click Box For Free View of Each Document |
Place An Order |
Distribution Agreement - DEF03 |
||
Exclusive License Agreement - DEF04 |
||
Joint Venture Agreement - DEF05 |
||
Marketing & Sales Only Joint Venture Agreement - DEF06 |
||
License Technology In Exchange For Stock Agreement - DEF13 |
||
Partnership Agreement - DEF07 |
||
Asset Purchase & Sale Agreement- DEF01 |
||
Stock Purchase & Sale Agreement: Common Stock, Shorter Version- DEF02 |
||
Stock Purchase & Sale Agreement: Common Stock, Longer Version- DEF11 |
||
Stock Purchase & Sale Agreement: Preferred Stock, Longer Version- DEF12 |
||
Promissory Note - DEF08 |
||
Non-Disclosure Agreement : DEF09 |
||
Shareholder Agreement - DEF10 |
c) It is essential for the minority partner to ensure his influence at
various levels:
Whereas the majority partner will, at least factually, have easy access
to information on the JV company, the minority partner will have to rely
on "watch dog" key personnel nominated by him and/or on
experts he may have the right to call in.
As already mentioned, the most important level to delegate such nominees
to, might be to that of director, which is where the day to day business
ensues. Depending on the purpose of the JV (see above), the weaker
partner should insist on the allocation of such tasks and
responsibilities to "his" directors and key personnel, which
are important to him. Apart from these "reserved tasks" other business decisions of
the directors should be subject to a majority, including the nominee of
the minority shareholder.
d) The minority shareholder should fix, in advance, the compensation of
the directors so that no excessive remuneration will be granted to the
nominees of the majority partner.
e) On the "upper level" (which, depending on the structure of
the JV company, will be a board or the shareholder meeting), the
minority shareholder should carefully negotiate a catalogue of business
matters (e.g., investments, loans) where his consenting vote is required
to pass a resolution; the same should apply to structural corporate
matters (capital increase, liquidation, merger, spin-off, etc.).
The minority shareholder should rather avoid a clause providing for
"dispute resolution in case of deadlocks" in order not to
dilute his veto.
f) Business plan, financing and at least the first budget, should be agreed in advance so that deadlocks in the initial phase of the JV can be avoided.
g) Another deadlock to the detriment of the minority shareholder might
occur in relation to the distribution of profit. Here, a bottom line of
the profit to be distributed as a dividend should be agreed in the
shareholder agreement (e.g., as a minimum percentage of the annual net
profit, or a figure depending on the amount of equity shown in the
balance sheet).
h) When dealing with the transfer of shares, it should be the weaker
partner who insists on a minimum period during which no transfer of
shares shall be admissible at all (blocking period). Only then will he
be in a position to get a secured return on his investment.
Later on, there might be a well-defined circle of "permitted
transferees", accompanied by the right of first refusal (or a
pre-emption-right) of the non-transferring partner.
If the investment turns out to be negative for the minority partner, he
would be well protected if granted a put option (at a price in line with
a well established method of valuation).
If he sells only a part of his shares, it is important for the minority
partner to maintain his minority rights (at least, to an appropriate
extent).
i) Provisions for the exit from the JV are of paramount importance for
the minority partner: The duration of the JV, either for a definite or
an indefinite period of time, will very much depend on the nature of the
project. Yet it will be even more important for the minority partner to
have the right of exit in cases where events occur making it
unacceptable for him to continue. (Such an event might be the change of
control over the majority partner.)
There exist various ways of exit:
-
The obvious variant is to liquidate the company.
Here, the minority partner should have the right to, at least, veto the way the assets are sold or distributed. Another point is whether a block sale of the whole business to the majority partner should be admissible?
It might be provided for that the minority partner gets back in kind specific important assets he initially contributed.
-
Another method of exit lies in the right to sell all the shares the JV
partner holds in the JV vehicle. Apart from the right of first refusal
(or a pre-emption right) the third party purchaser should be obliged to
continue the shareholder agreement so that the contractual rights of the
minority shareholder survive.
In that context, the option of the minority partner to simultaneously sell to the third-party purchaser its minority share (tag-along option) will be extremely valuable.
-
Finally, the parties may have agreed in advance the details for an
exit through an Initial Public Offering. Again, if the JV partners
retain control of the company, they should in advance define their
continuing rights after such public offering.
5. Additional Agreements
a) Often, the weakness of a partner results from the fact that the JV
vehicle will be successful only if it enters into additional agreements
with the "stronger" JV partner or with one of its affiliates.
Such agreements typically relate to the supply of goods and services, to
intellectual property, to the use of information technology or the lease
of factory premises. The first question is whether the individual
agreement will have been entered into at arm's length. This, however,
may not be the case at a later stage of the JV. From this viewpoint, it
would be in the interest of the "weaker" partner to provide
for a short term agreement (so that it must be re-negotiated at a later
time) or to allow the JV company to choose an additional third party or,
at least, to establish a mechanism of price adaptation, if possible.
b) The same applies to employment contracts with key personnel (in
particular, to pension agreements with senior staff).
Yet there is one essential thing, which cannot be put into any
contractual clause: Closing the "cultural gap" between the JV
partners so that the JV will be a continuing success for both the weak
and the strong partner.
Download Additional Amazing Deal Agreement and Term Sheet Templates For
Annual Subscription Members Only
Other Templates | File Description |
Exclusive License Agreement - Sample 1 | Template to develop an exclusive license agreement with royalties between two parties (Word Document) |
Exclusive License Agreement - Sample 2 | Another template to develop an exclusive license agreement with royalties between two parties (Word Document) |
Exclusive License Agreement - Sample 3 | Another template to develop an exclusive license agreement with royalties between two parties (Word Document) |
Non-Exclusive License Agreement | Template to develop a non-exclusive license agreement with royalties between two parties (Word Document) |
Agreement For Joint Technology Development, Licensing - Sample 1 | Template to develop a comprehensive joint technology development, licensing, and marketing agreement between parties (Word Document) |
Agreement For Joint Technology Development, Licensing - Sample 2 | Another template to develop a comprehensive joint technology development, licensing, and marketing agreement between parties (Word Document) |
Collaborative Research Agreement | Template agreement to develop the term and conditions for collaborative research between parties (Word Document) |
Joint Marketing Agreement - Sample 1 | Template to develop a joint marketing and distribution agreement with compensation between two parties (Word Document) |
Joint Marketing Agreement - Sample 2 | Another template to develop a joint marketing and distribution agreement with compensation between two parties (Word Document) |
How To Prepare A Business For Sale | Step-by-step action plan on the specific tactics of what you need to do prepare your business for a successful sale with the highest potential value (Word Document) |
Transitioning Your Company Through A Sale Or Merger | Presentation template with the step-by-step issues to be faced and processes involved as a company and the owners go through a business sale or merger. The step-by-step process is complete in that it starts from the first call/meeting and goes beyond post merger/acquisition integration (PowerPoint Document) |
Board Resolution Templates | General Business Templates | Intellectual Property (IP) Templates | Merger, Acquisition, and Joint Venture Templates |
Naming Board Members | Corporate Director Indemnity | IP Development & Transfer | Asset Purchase (2nd Version) |
Corporate Formation Consent | Employment Agreement | Assignment of Inventions | Acquisition of Joint Venture Interest |
Authorization of Joint Venture | Software License | Trademark Assignment | Assumption of Debt |
Limited Partnership (2nd Version) | Bill of Sale | ||
General Partnership | Checklist For Stock Sale | ||
Checklist For Asset Purchase | |||
Indemnity From Shareholder to Buyer |
Are questions preventing you from making a decision? Contact us and we will answer them.